Bayswell Park and the cliff-top setting
Choose Bayswell when a named sea-view room is a central part of the break. The separate hot-tub category changes both the setting and the room position. Leave time at the property if those features are what persuaded you to book.
Good for: Couples planning a room-led coastal stay.
Before you choose: Most bedrooms require stairs and there is no lift. The ground-floor hot-tub rooms should not be assumed to provide step-free bathroom or terrace access.
Queens Road and Dunmuir
Dunmuir is worth examining room by room. Its older main-house bedrooms, lower-ground standards and ground-floor Classics offer different access and space. That makes a direct conversation with the hotel particularly useful for a family or anyone avoiding stairs.
Good for: Visitors who need to agree a specific bedroom layout in advance.
Before you choose: The gravel car park, shower lip in one accessible category and entrance noise in another are meaningful details. Choose the named room rather than a broad accessibility label.
High Street, harbour and a town-first stay
Keep the central streets and harbour as the daytime focus if you want a short visit without turning it into a tour of East Lothian. John Muir connections give the town its own story, while the coast provides an outdoor alternative.
Good for: First visits and travellers arriving without a car.
Before you choose: A broader beach or country-park outing requires another journey. Check that route separately rather than extending a town stroll on impulse.