Church Street: a Swan hotel stay
The Swan offers en-suite bedrooms in a Georgian hotel setting. Compare it when you want time at the hotel as well as in the bookshops, asking about the particular room and any private event on your dates.
Good for: Couples and visitors who want a hotel base for a leisurely town break.
Before you choose: All rooms are described with showers, but not every room has a bath. Ask for the bathroom feature you need rather than relying on a general photograph.
Lion Street: choose the Old Black Lion room carefully
The Old Black Lion lists singles, twins and doubles, which makes it useful for comparing solo or friends’ arrangements. One single category has a private separate bathroom; the other single is en-suite. That distinction should be explicit in the reservation.
Good for: Solo travellers, friends and visitors who prefer an inn format.
Before you choose: Confirm stairs and room position around evening events. The homepage gives inconsistent Sunday dining information, so reserve a meal only after checking the current service.
Book town or a Black Mountains walking base?
Hay can occupy a full day without a drive: choose the shops that match your interests and fit the castle around its current programme. A hill outing belongs to a different kind of day, with route, weather and transport considered before departure.
Good for: Book lovers deciding whether to add an active countryside day.
Before you choose: A two-night stay cannot give unlimited browsing time and a substantial mountain circuit without compromise. Decide which experience matters most.